The Great Sports Compromise: Equal Trans Athlete Allocation—Problem Solved
- Wissam Elgamal
- Mar 7
- 2 min read
For years, the left and right have been locked in an endless tug-of-war over transgender athletes in women’s sports—a debate as interminable as a political filibuster. But what if the solution was as simple as ensuring every team gets an equal share of the magic? Enter the Equal Trans Athlete Allocation Rule—a plan so straightforward it practically writes itself.

The Rule: Equal Trans Athlete Allocation
To satisfy everyone, every team gets exactly the same number of transgender athletes. This equal distribution is the ultimate leveler—if one team gets a dose of my brilliant idea, every team does.
How It Works:
Equal Allocation for AllEvery team is assigned an identical quota of trans athletes, determined by the league’s consensus. If the league agrees on two per team, then every team gets two—no more, no less. It’s fairness on paper, and fairness in play.
Substitution RulesThe trans athletes will be treated like strategic substitutes, not necessarily playing every minute. They can be subbed in during key moments, offering teams that secret competitive edge without turning the game into a free-for-all.
Position RestrictionsTo avoid any team assembling an unstoppable “dream team” of trans athletes in every pivotal position, certain roles may have limits. This keeps the competition balanced, ensuring no team can corner the market on any particular advantage.
Physical StandardsAll athletes, regardless of background, must meet standardized physical criteria—hormone levels, fitness benchmarks, and, yes, even that secret handshake with Big Dog (figuratively speaking). This guarantees that every player is tuned to the same frequency of fair play.
Fair Play BalanceBy ensuring every team has the same number of transgender athletes, the rule bridges the partisan divide. Inclusion meets fairness on a level playing field, so both sides get a piece of the pie—no team hogs the spotlight.
But What About Individual Sports?
Here's the candid part: I haven’t figured out a one-size-fits-all solution for individual sports. For now, if you’re itching to crack that nut, you’re free to go at it as you see fit. Consider it an open invitation for further innovation—no hand-holding from Big Dog on this one.
A Caveat for Transgender Men
And here’s an extra twist: this solution works for transgender men too. That means, by extending the equal allocation to include trans men, biologically assigned women now get their chance to shine on the field as well. It’s a win-win that opens the door for even more inclusivity and fairness—ensuring all athletes get their shot at the spotlight.
Final Thoughts
Politics have turned sports into an arena for endless debate, but with the Equal Trans Athlete Allocation Rule, we can finally let fairness and inclusion share the field. By giving every team the same number of trans athletes—and extending the system to cover transgender men—we cut through the partisan bickering and bring a little common sense to the game. My solution isn’t just a win for sports—it’s a blueprint for solving national debates by treating everyone equally.